Mina Kupfermann

Home
   Publications    Exhibitions   About

Cary Nelson
Whether the sun in the center of the panels framed by Shani and Keshet is rising or setting one cannot say...


For a while, people thought Shani Louk might have been among those kidnapped alive and taken to Gaza as a hostage, but a skull fragment found in Israel on the road leading out of the festival grounds and identified as hers through DNA testing put that hope to an end. She was born to an Israeli father and a German mother in Israel on February 7, 2001. She spent some time in Portland, Oregon, later becoming a freelance tattoo artist in Tel Aviv. The IDF found her body in Rafah in southern Gaza on May 17, 2024. She was among the dead that the Hamas ghouls brought to their lair. Her parents finally had a body to bury. Meanwhile, she is interred in our imaginations.

What that internment will mean long-term is impossible to say. Shani Louk’s image has also found a place in recent graphic work. An online search will reveal a number of painted portraits. A photo of her with her head slightly tilted back and to the side has inspired several artists. The photo and the portraits it has inspired before long triumphed over the Hamas murder tableau that opens this chapter. I place two of the resulting images, one each by Benzi Brofman and Mina Kupfermann in explicit contrast with Hamas’s brutal truck bed photo. We can think of this broadly as a struggle over the character of 10/7 visual representation. I will offer other examples in the form of BDS movement posters.

Benzi Brofman’s luminous, idealized portrait of Shani Louk is one of over a hundred partly photorealist portraits of the dead and kidnapped that the Israeli artist has included in his October 7 series. He was at the Nova site the day before the massacre for a pre-rave event and thus barely missed being caught up in the horror of that day. Had he stayed, he might have been killed. His black-and-white and largely gray images with color highlights, are both private hauntings and public commemorations. Some are massive street installations painted on building walls from Amsterdam to Barcelona to Berlin to London to Tel Aviv, while others are large scale studio portraits painted on canvas.

He is self-taught. The street art versions sometimes include painted phrases such as “BRING THEM HOME NOW.” They are also contextualized within the public spaces they adorn. He works with a metal-tipped hose connected to a humming spray-paint machine, sometimes holding a photo of the subject in his other hand on his cell phone. The limited palette gives the uncanny sense that the 10/7 portraits have floated through memory and dream into visibility. The portraits return to us from the past in which their subjects lived, stripped of literal violence but still filtered through collective suffering. Gathered in a gallery, the portraits create an eerie community of commemoration.

British Israeli artist Mina Kupfermann features Shani Louk as one of two framing portraits for her multi-panel 2025 painting Triptych. As David Hirsh, British sociologist and director of the London Centre for the Study of Contemporary Antisemitism, writes in the folder accompanying the 2025 London exhibit Witness, Kupfermann “re-imagines the medieval Christian artform of painting on three wooden panels . . . in lieu of religious icons.”

As Kupfermann confirmed in an email conversation with me, that matches her intent. She wanted the form to evoke the dual legacy of Christian hypocrisy about Judaism and the shared legacy of moral instruction in the two traditions. Louk and Keshet Casarotti-Kalfa, friends who fled the festival in the same car until they separated to seek medical treatment and who were both then murdered by the terrorists, function as Adam and Eve to the left and right of the sun that blazes ambiguously in the center panel. As Kupfermann wrote to me, “Keshet and Shani are portrayed as saints, ethereal beings existing partway between worlds, representing pure good, and offering the viewer a way to encounter and process the unbearable.” A glowing, androgynous photo of Keshet alive has circulated widely as a symbol of transcendence incarnate and an anguished commemoration of what was lost on 10/7. They are contrasted here because Louk’s tilted gaze is open and engaged, whereas Casarotti-Kalfa’s is shadowed as though veiled. For Kupfermann, that treatment signals his overshadowing by the power of antisemitism. His glowing blond image is no longer available. Here both are standing and still alive, but already bound to the fate they would face. The two murdered rave participants are linked in another unsettling way; Shani was thought to be alive for several days, and Keshet’s fate was uncertain because his body was not found for four days. In this our new world, both young adults are here tied in string that doubles as protective cradle and restraint. The webbing can symbolize the weave of 10/7 and subsequent meanings in which these two people are now embedded, meanings that increase as their images circulate. The layered work is consequently subject to multiple interpretations. The viewer is invited to walk around the installation, engage with it, meditate on its implications. The contrasting treatment of the two victims is designed to engage the viewer in the choices all of us have—to embrace enlightenment or succumb to antisemitism’s mechanisms for entanglement.

On the reverse side of Shani’s and Keshet’s portraits are half spheres filled with winding pipes or tubes. Are these the equivalent of a marvelous clockwork mechanism or the pipes, valves, and buckets of a demonic industrial machine? We do not know, though for the artist the meaning is clear. The pipework represents the intersecting mechanisms of antisemitism, “the propaganda machine, the educational, political and other institutions, the media, the arts institution itself.” For the two young adults were once treasured by those who loved them and subsequently reviled as representative Jews by their Hamas murderers. If Triptych is closed, the two panels on the back combine to form a sphere enclosing the inner panels, a sphere bordered by slivers of a metallic surface, its silvery glow embodying its historical allure. The construction of social meaning is at work in that pipework cluster. It also means there is an inner and outer sphere in the work. Whether the sun in the center of the panels framed by Shani and Keshet is rising or setting one cannot say, but it cannot entirely penetrate the darkened world below that fills nearly half of the central image. That is the polarized post-10/7 world in which we live. Brofman reaches for a glimpse of affirmation, Kupfermann for complication and ambiguity. The pastels she selects for the two figures are beautiful but muted.

Text from College Zionists Confront the Abyss: The Aftermath of October 7 in Higher Education and Its Consequences for Progressive Politics (2026) by Cary Nelson, Jubilee Professor of Liberal Arts and Sciences Emeritus, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, United States, Affiliated Faculty Member, University of Haifa

In College Zionists Confront the Abyss, Cary Nelson, former President of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), examines the rise of antisemitism and antizionism in higher education following October 7. Drawing on extensive research, the book explores the role of university faculty, the 2024 campus encampments and demonstrations worldwide, the influence of social media, and the challenges facing academic institutions. It also examines the murder of Shani Louk and the powerful imagery that emerged in its aftermath, considering how visual representations shape public memory and understanding. Nelson concludes by proposing steps to address antisemitism and safeguard the future of higher education.

The book has attracted praise from distinguished scholars and commentators. Jeffrey Herf, Distinguished University Professor Emeritus of History at the University of Maryland and a leading historian of modern Germany, antisemitism and political ideology, describes it as “an intellectual’s classic effort to place the voice of reason in the service of truth”. Donna Robinson Divine, Morningstar Professor Emerita of Jewish Studies and Professor Emerita of Government at Smith College, and former President of the Association for Israel Studies, calls it “the essential gateway to understanding this unhinged moment”. Hussein Aboubakr Mansour, the Egyptian-American author and political analyst whose work examines antisemitism, Islamist ideology and Middle Eastern politics, hails it as “a work of profound moral and intellectual courage”.